This personal jazz journal will continue now in a different format - as a weblog.
From 25th June, 2004, I will not be adding anything more here but will maintain the journal in weblog form at...
...being the diary of my ongoing struggle to learn to
play jazz - from scratch.
2001
16th July
This jazz thing has been going on for some time already but I'm still
at the beginning so I thought I'd better get writing before it became
really too late to do it.
So, the background. Back in 1977 I borrowed an alto sax and started learning
some scales. I wanted to play jazz but I didn't think it would sound right
on the horn. The sax only lasted a week or two because the embouchure
didn't come right away. I suppose I should have had a lesson. That was
that. Over the years I did other bits of improvising, including a few
albums involving four horns (all me), then two (with another player) horns,
then three horns (with two others). None of this was jazz.
Then, 1988, or thereabouts, I had a jazz piano lesson with some bloke
in Hampstead. He went on about learning all the 2-5-1 chord changes. I
did it for a while but didn't get the point. I suppose it was my failure,
but I don't think this person had any teaching skills - nothing he said
seemed very stimulating.
Then, last year, Jim Rattigan, horn (French) player and friend got a CD
out called "Unfamiliar Guise". Very nice, it was, and I interviewed
him for the horn magazine, and gave him a really good review to help him
shift CDs. It's a good recording but not what I would want to play. In
fact, I don't know what I'm looking for, really. I just want to be able
to play jazz. Simple.
Jim's album got me thinking about jazz, and the horn, and I talked with
him quite a lot about how you learn it. He gave me some photocopied sheets
of "all" the jazz scales and I spent hours during the summer
of 2000 learning some of them. I also ordered an instrument from Yamaha
- the "Marching French Horn" in Bb, on a hunch that this would
make the perfect forward facing jazz horn for horn players. I have named
it the "Frunting Horn" even though 18 months have passed and
there's still no sign of it. The scales dried up and stopped flowing.
The next wave came during May of 2001 when I was on a short tour with
Peter Erskine and the Creative Jazz Orchestra. I was one of three horns
(French) playing written out parts of Peter's music. I heard Kenny Wheeler
live for the first time and spoke to him a bit (he only lives a couple
of minutes walk from our house). What he said was encouraging - for example,
he uses the Aebersold books, still! He's 72 and still practicing and developing
his playing. Incredible.
At last, I stopped waiting for the Frunting Horn to arrive and got out,
instead, the beautiful little Besson cornet that Mum and Dad gave me for
my 40th birthday and ordered a pile of Aebersold playalong books.
18th July
The cornet is going well. I think I have a useful range - fairly comfortable
up to about top C - and the fingering is mostly sorted, although there's
usually a glitch around high E (same as top A on the horn) where I'm trying
very hard to remember to play it with no valves pressed down, whereas
it's best on the horn with 1st and 2nd down.
I'm also gradually getting the register shift sorted in my mind. Although
the fingering almost exactly matches that of the horn, if I think in horn
pitch, I have decided to make the shift into thinking and reading in Bb
as this will make reading music much easier in the long term. Thus I have
to re-educate my pitch sense, when I am in cornet mode, to one fourth
higher. I get lost sometimes - sort of a pitch whiteout where I have no
idea what notes I am playing. My fingers and lips know but my conscious
mind is nowhere. Granted, this has always happened when playing the horn,
but now that I am formally learning jazz I really need always to know
what notes I am playing, what chords, scales, etc... This is new for me.
My previous improvisations have always been instinctive, with almost no
role for the conscious mind. Jazz, however, needs the guiding keel of
definite harmonic navigation. It's a discipline I'm trying to learn -
determined to learn.
Oren Marshall is a brilliant and unconventional tuba player with at least
one leg in the world of jazz, although I don't know how well versed he
is in actual jazz improvisation and, for that matter, I don't really know
what it is to be a jazz tubist. He visited me today, partly for a run
over at the Hollow Ponds and partly to "do some playing" together.
It was an interesting lesson for me. It made me realise that I was actually
quite embarrassed to let go and play "jazzilly" in front of
him. When I eventually did - on some blues in concert F - Oren said, in
his usually flattering way, that I was loaded with all the right tools
but that I didn't have the feel. Nice of him - and I suppose I kind of
knew that. He also said a lot of interesting, thoughtful stuff about how
it can be refreshing to hear someone new to jazz playing their own unique
stuff and that the "novice" can have a certain amount of freedom
that perhaps would be difficult for an experienced jazzer to express.
A difficult concept to argue, I think, but it was very nice of him to
be so encouraging. We played a few rounds of blues but I don't think I
achieved much.
We talked about Derek Bailey a bit - I've done a fair bit of improvising
(free, non-jazz) with Derek, donkey's years ago, and so has Oren only
much more recently. It seems Oren was able to make much more sense of
Derek's style of improvisation, which always had me confused. I told him
about my general frustration with performing free improvisation to which
he had some interesting responses.
19th July
Went to Wood Green, to the house of Noel Langley to try some strange horns.
He had a Holton Marching French Horn in Bb, and a Conn Mellophone in F.
I didn't like the mellophone - the F being, curiously for a horn player,
rather an alien pitch for me. I came away with the Holton to try for a
while. I might buy it, if the price is right, and do it up as it's in
a pretty bad state.
20th July
I had a jazz lesson with Ken Bartels of Loughton. I got his name from
Bernard O'Neill, the bass player from down our road, who said that Ken
would be a very good teacher. He plays flute, single reeds and keyboards.
I think Bernard was right. I came away from the lesson with, for the first
time, a clear route into jazz. Ken's got me playing from the Aebersold
jazz book Vol. 42, Blues in All Keys. I had a minor breakthrough when
he told me that the blues scale works, more or less, all the way through
the blues so that, for example, if you are playing the blues in C, then
you can get through the whole sequence using only the notes C, Eb, F,
Gb, G, and Bb without having to change scale at each chord change. He
explained that it is quite a good discipline to go through the whole book
playing each blues song using only the blues-scale notes of that particular
key. I feel sure this is exactly what I need. I learned from Oren that
I have a tendency to overcomplicate things and try to play everything
all at once, and Ken reinforced this.
When I have got the hang of sticking exclusively to the blues scales I
have to go through the book again this time using only Aebersold's written
black notes, that is to say, the simple chord notes for every chord as
they change through the piece. I have to try to make it interesting, musical
but without straying from the simple clusters of chord notes. he demonstrated
this, on his clarinet, and was able to play really attractive, interesting
stuff using the simplest of notes. It was amazing to hear how rich and
complex it sounded given that he was using so few notes. He's good.
So, at last I have proper homework to do! Things should now move in a
better, more methodical and systematic direction. No more groping in the
dark. And I won't need another lesson for a couple of months because it
will take me that long, I think, to get through everything we covered
today.
21st July
I've been trying to think about what I want to achieve by learning jazz.
I think it's that I want to be able to analyse what I'm doing, as I do
it, so that I'm always aware of what I'm doing. That is it, I think.
I don't want to plan everything I play, consciously - that would be dull,
contrived and too slow a process to come up with anything but safe material.
On the other hand I don't want to let my unconscious autopilot do just
anything it chooses, as I have always done in the past with my improvising.
It's fine for free improvising but not much use for particular chord sequence.
It has to be a question of the balance between the automatic trawling
for "licks", learned patterns and inventing brand new material
or recombining patterns in new ways.
This is why I think Ken Bartels is right when he tells me that I should
try to learn to play much more simply, using limited ranges of notes,
for example only the blues scale (that's my first load of homework), and
try to keep track of where I am all both harmonically and within the musical
sequence.
What has always happened, whenever I launch into some blues for example,
is that I would race around not knowing what notes I am playing - I suppose
trying to go straight for the finished product without any considerations
for the means whereby. Where have I heard that story before? Read some
stuff I wrote for the Horn Magazine about the Alexander Technique. Click.
22nd July
But where has this urge to learn jazz come from? I think it's been there,
just below the surface, for a very long time. It's come to the surface
now partly because it's now or never - I'm 43. I have a slight sense of
urgency and a feeling that at last I'm doing something I've been wanting
to do for a very long time.
It's also a fascinating learning process and to a large extent it's uncharted
territory for someone like me, already possessing a certain amount of
technique from a parallel discipline but not the language itself.
Another aspect of this is that I'm finding the study extremely satisfying,
musically. The way I'm practicing the cornet is completely different from
any way I've ever practiced the horn. Yesterday, for example, I spent
part of the evening going through all the modes in all keys, first saying
the name (i.e. Db Mixolydian) then trying to play them by ear but also
picturing the geography, as if written down, so that I'm aware of which
notes I'm playing, this being the hardest part because I'm not used to
holding the visual map in my mind while playing.
I've noticed a fingering difficulty emerging: during the modes practice
it happened quite a lot that when going from 2+3 to 1 the 2nd finger would
come up slightly later that the 3rd making quite a messy transition. I
need to isolate this problem and work out some specific finger exercises
to clear problem. I wonder why I find this compelling - exciting even.
25th July
We are on holiday in a quiet cottage in Essex. I did a lot of cornet practice
today. Must have been at least three hours. I went from book to book (of
which I now have many) fiddling around trying to find useful things to
practice. Played through all the major blues in Aebersold Vol (?) using
only notes in the tonic blues scale each time. Also I tried some of these
using just the chord notes indicated in black by the Aebersold texts,
as set by Ken for my homework. Later on I went through all the major pentatonics
which seem to be coming surprisingly easily. I remember whoever it was
playing sax in the Aebersold book sounding so fluent and easy and wondering
how he kept track of which notes out of the major scales to leave out.
Now that it's coming quickly I find it's, as much as anything, getting
the sound of the pentatonic firmly established in the mind. Also it helped
to discover that it's the fourth and the seventh which are missed out
of the major pentatonics. I suppose these are the ones which hint in directions
of modulation, sort of destabilising influences, and without them both
the scale seems very well defined in its tonality. Having got this in
mind it has got rapidly easier.
I still sometimes lose where I am, pitchwise, sometimes reverting to horn
equivalents, though it's happening less often than it did at first.
27th July
Yesterday I didn't do very much blowing and I was worried that I'd burnt
myself out with too much practice in the few previous days, but on the
other hand my energy might have been low due perhaps to the double dosing
of antihistamine I've been taking each day because of the close proximity
of grass pollen all around our holiday cottage.
Today was better, though. We drove up from Essex to north Norfolk - moving
to a different cottage for another week of holiday. On the way I did quite
a lot of work in the Locrian mode, trying to familiarise myself with its
sound. I had a small breakthrough in discovering that it has both a perfect
fourth and a flattened fifth. With this I discovered that if I sung (in
my head) the root, then the fourth, then a semitone higher (the flat fifth)
I could then sing the scale up or down with all the right notes. Locrian
is easy to check as you work on it - simply start on its second note and
you should have a major scale. If you don't then that wasn't locrian.
Then, when we got to the Norfolk cottage, I tried it out on the cornet
and found that with those three notes preceding each scale I could play
all my locrians without fumbling around for the notes. All I need to do
now is plenty of this, every day for a week or so, and then I should have
freedom to improvise in all the locrians, which I believe covers the chords
known as half-diminished.
30th July
The task ahead has got a little bit clearer now. I need to learn how to
read from chord symbols. I should carry written sequences around with
me and work on them in my head. Yes, that's a good idea. I could photocopy
a few from the Real Book and carry them around with me. I don't necessarily
have to have the instrument with me.
I think I need to learn to "see" each chord symbol as a harmony
flavour and a scale - sort of a grid of possibilities within that flavour.
Having learned that then I should learn how to imagine how the following
one sounds while I am still playing the first. I think this ability must
take a long time and a lot of work to acquire - and the method of acquiring
this skill must be efficient. Working out methods is where I am right
now.
5th August
I've discovered a useful way forward, for myself involving the use of
the Aebersold books and both cornet and keyboard. I arrived at this idea
by playing with some of the Aebersold "dominant seventh workout"
tracks sitting at the piano, cornet in hand, playing alternately on each
instrument and wondering if the constant transpositions from C to Bb and
back again was going to help my "feel" of cornet pitch or just
confuse me. I could see that this alternation of instruments was going
to be very good for me, for a couple of reasons. One of the issues Hal
Crook is very hot on, in A New Approach to Practising Improvisation, is
learning how to leave spaces, i.e. not to keep playing all the time -
a huge problem in improvisation. He devotes a large chunk of the book
to saying over and over again how important this is and giving technical
exercises to get used to leaving gaps in solos. At first I thought it
was going to be easy, but now I can see why he attaches such importance
to it - it's so bloody difficult to do it! I keep finding myself playing
continuously, which doesn't give me time to think much about what I'm
going to play and tires out my lip in no time. Alternating keyboard and
cornet solves this problem easily, for both instruments, so that's two
solutions for the price of one.
While alternating between piano and cornet I had the idea that it would
be a lot easier if the keyboard was in Bb. Thus I rigged up the the little
Yamaha DJX synth I bought last year (for the kids, ostensibly, but so
far they only play the preset, which I always turn off) to transpose two
semitones down and soon discovered what a useful tool this was going to
be. One of the problems I still have is that my fingers and chops keep
playing away but my mind loses track of at notes I'm playing. Alternating
with the keyboard, with its visual reminder of exactly where I am all
the time is going to be a brilliant trainer for me - I think. So, I feel
this is a really positive step.
6th August
Ho-ho! Just bought a new toy on an impulse, while shopping in Chappells
for music stands and an Aulos sopranino recorder for Zak (3). It's a Yamaha
QY70 "music sequencer". A fabulous portable (tiny) box of tricks
with which I can (when I've read he manual a few times) program accompaniments
for my jazz practice. It was reduced in price by £150 with a "find
it cheaper anywhere else and we'll kill you" pledge attached to it.
I also bought a very usful-looking book called "1001 Jazz Licks"
Jesus, I'm spending a lot on this jazz lark! Thank goodness the cornet
didn't cost me anything.
August 9th
The QY70 is great! I've learned how to program it to change chords through
a specific sequence and I spent about 90 minutes late into the night,
cup mute firmly in, playing Locrians scales over all the X flat minor
ninth chords. The Bossanova setting is really nice, but there are loads
of different ones I can use. It's going to be a doddle to use. All I need
now is loads of time - the problem is that it's school holidays right
now and it's very difficult to find time to practice, apart from late
into the night.
10th August
Here's another useful exercise I just arrived at after some work on Aebersold,
"Blues in all keys". Having learned what the the chord notes
and scale notes are (track 11, Blues in Ab -for trumpet) because Aebersold
writes them all in for you, I found it hard to ignore them and tha I couldn't
avoid playing simply chords and scales. So I wrote just the chord symbols
on a post-it and stuck it in the page - effectively taking away one of
the crutches.. Then I found that because I still kept drifting away from
knowing what notes I was playing I needed a way of making me focus this
in relation to the given chords, so I went through the sequence playing
just the thirds of every chord.
This is a great exercise for me. I must go through the entire book(s)
doing this. It will be a great help.
23rd August
Having got back from holidays with cornet I had to check my hornplaying
was still working before heading off to Edinburgh with the Britten Sinfonia,
to play some stuff by James Macmillan. This would be followed by a week
of film sessions (Peter Pan) for Joel McNeely. To my great relief the
horn playing seemed hardly changed. Perhaps a little unfocussed in the
high register but elsewhere, if anything, improvements had taken place.
How completely brilliant! I really didn't know what sort of damage I might
have done so I was very relieved.
What struck me most of all was the difference of practice technique. With
the cornet I had been playing scales and arpeggios and improvising bits
of melody and jazz licks. With the horn, on the other hand, I found myself
playing long tones with crescendi and diminuendi and bathing in the sheer
loveliness of the sound. The cornet is nice but it really doesn't have
that fascinating, hypnotic timbre. I don't think I could have spent thirty
years practicing long notes on a trumpet like I have with the horn.
Another difference which became obvious was that rotary valves sound very
different to pistons. I had no idea about this before learning the cornet.
It's not just a left hand versus right hand thing, it's a different mechanism
with a different sound effect. The rotary valves of a horn are capable
of giving a very quick change, more like a switch than a valve, whereas
the piston can be moved slower if required and the half-valve sounds are
more useful and easy to use than those of the horn. I wonder now what
a modern piston horn would feel like to play. I must earmark that idea
for a future project.
I'm still working at Locrians (Ø), diminished whole-tone scales
(C7+9), and Diminished (beginning with the semitone) (C7-9).
29th August
On the way back from taking the kids to nursery this morning I bumped
into the great Sir Kenny Wheeler - who lives just around the corner. It
was a great bumping into. As soon as I got home I wrote this letter to
him:
Dear Kenny,
It was great to see you this morning.
Here, as promised are the two minidisk copies of the concert at "The
Wardrobe" in Leeds with Peter Erskine and the Creative Jazz Orchestra,
25th May 2001. It's as good a recording as one can get, I think, being
digital copies direct from the master. It was very kindly copied for me
by Steve Shepherd of "Somethin' Else" who engineered the recording
for the BBC. I pestered the poor fellow for weeks, by email, until he
finally cracked under the nervous strain and sent me a copy.
For me, that little tour was a great musical event. It's not often one
gets to play with ones musical heroes (that's you, and Peter and John
Taylor) so I couldn't rest until I had a copy of the recording. And talking of pestering
You did say this morning that I should come over sometime and play with
you and we talked about arranging a date in October. I'm back from Japan
around 4th October and I have put a note in my diary to phone you up and
harass you until we fix up a date. I've been doing a lot of practice on
my cornet and things are beginning - just beginning - to take shape. I'm
very much a novice, though and I hope you won't be too appalled at my
efforts, or my shaking legs (I'll probably be very nervous).
I'm very serious about learning to play jazz. I've been hard at it for
a couple of months now, on my cornet (and I've ordered a flugelhorn) and
my fingers are getting to know the scales. Luckily, it hasn't completely
screwed up my horn-playing embouchure, or confused the fingers of my other
hand. I wrote a letter to you a few weeks ago but in the end never sent
it because I thought it would be too much of an imposition on you, that
you would be too busy, etc. What my letter said was that I'd love to have
a jazz cornet lesson with you sometime and was wondering if you ever did
any teaching and if you would consider taking me on, even for just one
lesson, etc
So you can imagine my delight on seeing you this morning and hearing you
actually invite me over to play. Incredible!
Today, I will do sixteen hours of practice.
I hope you enjoy the recording - and I'll give you a call in early October.
All the best,
Pip Eastop
29th August
Now that I think about it a bit, I realise I'm rather scared of going
to Kenny's house and playing jazz with him - him on the piano and me on
the cornet. He's probably brilliant on the piano - I mean, he's the most
modest and self effacing man on the planet, and he says he can "play
the piano a little bit". This probably means he's brilliant.
5th September
My second lesson with Ken Bartels. Unsurprisingly we started where we
had left off and this felt like me showing him my homework - a strange
feeling as it's some 25 years since I left school. The homework was playing
through the Aebersold"Blues in all keys" first sticking exclusively
to the blues scale of each key, secondly using only the given chord notes
to build the tunes. I told him I had worked on it for quite hard for a
couple of weeks but then had got "sidetracked" by such erotic
as Locrian modes and diminished whole-tone scales. I was crap at my homework
- which was a bit embarrassing - and the end result was that the same
homework still stands for the next lesson. Groan.
For the second half of the lesson we did some keyboard work which was
very interesting and my keyboard homework is to learn my 11-V-1 progressions,
in all keys and in both hands. It's a lot of work. He also recommended
a couple of books, which I have ordered - John Mehegan's "Contemporary
Styles for the Jazz Pianist", and Mark Levine's "The Jazz Piano
Book".
7th September
The Frunting Horn has finally arrived. What a long wait! Just about two
years, I reckon. Anyway, it's lovely. Nice and light, quite horn-like
in its sound but not in its articulation, which is smoother and more vocal
thanks to piston, rather than rotary valves.
Actually if feels more like a low cornet than a horn. Interestingly,
the top C (concert F) only works when you play it loud. When quiet the
note isn't really there. Bummer. However, I might be able to fix that
by putting a false hand or something like that in the bell. It might look
stupid but it may be worth it. Hell, what am I saying? It will look stupid!
I'd better not go too high on it.
15th September
Just started reading "Harmony
with Lego Bricks", by Conrad Cork. It looks to be an extremely
well thought out and insightful manual.
2002
17th April
Hmmm... It's been 7 months since I entered anything here. What happened?
I think I got a bit bogged down and lost my momentum. I had my third keyboard
lesson with Ken, in October, and we decided I would come back for another
one when I felt needed to rather than book up the next lesson there and
then.
Kenny phoned up and left a message with Carrie asking how I was getting
on and if I still wanted to go and have a blow with him. I was finding
it a bit difficult to pluck up the courage to call him so it was great
he called or perhaps nothing would have happened. I went around to his
place on 18th December. I was quite nervous and worried about having to
play something to him. Would he laugh at me? I felt a bit silly with my
cornet and unable to ask him the right sort of question. He's a bit of
an awkward fellow too, which didn't help much. Eventually I found myself
asking him what goes on in his head when he's reading chord symbols, improvising
over them. He really wasn't able to tell me but something useful did come
out of our meeting: I discovered what for me was THE crucial thing, which
was that he always knows what note he's on and what the "flavour"
of the chord is. I had already come to this realisation for myself but
Kenny kind of hammered it home and a result of this was that I set my
resolve to light up the part of my mind which monitors what notes I am
playing, the actual names of them and/or their positions on the stave.
A consciously visual, non-aural analogue of the pitches I am playing.
He put on one of the tracks from the Bill Evans book in the Aebersold
series and got me to play along with it. He seemed pretty impressed with
my "ear", and somewhat mystified when I told him I had no idea
what notes I was playing. We both came to the conclusion that I had to
find a way of knowing what notes I am playing. So from that moment - an
important one, which got me working at the jazz again - I put a lot of
energy into that.
Kenny Wheeler very kindly lent me one of his flugel horns. It's a beauty
with a gorgeous copper bell section and an absolute delight to play -
made by Kanstul. It's incredibly well in tune. Here's a photo:
13th April
Unless I was dreaming, today I played at the Vortex (a jazz club in London)
with Kenny! He was making a guest appearance with the Evan Parker Trio
and asked me to come along. At first I thought he meant for me just to
listen but it turned out he wanted me to actually play! I was stunned
and amazed, and I only agreed to join him because he said we would be
playing "free" jazz rather than jazz jazz - so it would be relatively
easy.
The first thing we played was a duet - just Kenny and me, in two sections
- Kenny on the trumpet, me on flugel, followed by Kenny on flugel, me
on horn. It's hard to say if it was any good or not but it was certainly
interesting and great fun. We made a lot of noise. Needless to say, Kenny
was great - firing off powerful torrents of scaleic and arpeggiated notes,
all fascinating. I made various squawks and rips and noodled around trying
not to get in the way too much and mess things up.
Nearly all of the free jazz I've done before has been with non jazzers
so this was very different to the kind of stuff I used to play with Derek
Bailey back in the eighties, for example.
After that we played for 40 minutes or so with Even Parker's trio. My
abiding memory is of the sensation of playing the flugel, standing up,
the sound firing outwards in the direction I was facing - something of
a novelty for a rear-facing (French)horn player.
After that I drove Kenny home.
10th May
Played a gig at Westminster Abbey with London Brass. I knew John Barclay
would be playing so I took along my SmithWatkins to see what he thought
of it. He liked it. It's a good setup.
He couldn't have been more encouraging. This is what he said: "If
you do another year on that [practicing the trumpet] you'll be as good
[at jazz] as anyone". That's so nice of him, even though it is wildly
inaccurate.
24th May
Went to The Valve (great shop) today,
to look at cases and buy a harmon mute. I ordered a "triple"
case which will hold both a trumpet and a flugelhorn. Should take a month
or so to arrive.
I found myself looking at mouthpieces and bought a very intriguing one
made of transparent polycarbonate. It's unbreakable, won't get stuck in
the leadpipe and always feels warm to the lips. Here's a picture of it.
27th May
Amazing - Carrie (my wife) went around to Sir Kenny Wheeler's house and
bought one of his trumpets from him for me, it being my birthday today.
It's a SmithWatkins - a very wonderful instrument. It has a large bell
in quite thin yellow lacquered brass and a choice of six leadpipes for
me to experiment with. They seem to make quite a difference to the sound
and to the intonation of the very high notes but it will probably be years
before I know which one is the best all-rounder for me.
Thanks, Kenny, for parting with this lovely trumpet (for such an insanely
low price) - and thanks, Carrie, for such a cool birthday present!
(This instrument has some weird bits stuck on. Please
ignore them. I'm not ready to go public with these just yet!)
28th May
Valentin Garvie came to visit today for a jam. He's recently landed a
great job - principal trumpet with Ensemble Modern, based in Frankfurt.
He's a wonderful trumpet player - from Argentina - and a really simpatico
bloke.
The first thing I did was to get him to listen to me playing on a Vincent
Bach "ordinary" mouthpiece and then switch to the transparent
polycarbonate one for comparison. Amazingly he knew straight away that
one of them was a plastic one - and knew which one it was!
However, he did concede that it is indeed a very good mouthpiece.
Valentin Garvie, May 2002
24th June
Trying to get a bit of practice in every day. More books and playalongs
have arrived, so no shortage of stuff to work on. The trumpet and the
flugel are hanging up next to the piano, and the cornet (and mute) are
upstairs next to the bed. Most of the playalongs and tons of other jazz
recordings are on minidisc so I've always got stuff to listen to or play-along
with. Also, my Revo has an ever increasing selection of "Grigson"
grids to study.
It's going quite well, although I detect a certain reluctance to get stuck
into any standards. I'm not sure quite why this is but I'm hoping that
Kenny might help me work this out when I go to see him this afternoon.
He's reluctantly agreed to see me for some kind of "lesson"
although it's clear he doesn't want to be a teacher. I think what I should
do is ask him to help me work on Stella - I think I have a bit of a foothold
in that one.
What I really need is a tame pianist to help me work on some tunes. I'm
going to phone Julian Jacobson in a few weeks, when he's back from a cruise,
and I'm hoping we can work up some tunes together.
The "LoadsOfModes" is working well. I think I'll know them all
in a couple of weeks and then I'll just have to start speeding them up.
There is a tonguing difference between the horn and the trumpet. It's
a larger mass of air inside the horn so starting it and stopping it takes
a bit more clout and steadier air pressure. This is the dreaded "support"
but I hate the term it means totally different things to different people.
I don't think the trumpet needs any less of it than the horn but the tongue
has to be used in quite a different way. I'm hoping that I'll be able
to switch tonguing styles as I switch instruments - rather like people
who play both violin and viola have to learn to switch gears as move from
one to the other.
27th June
I went to The Valve and bought a very nice case for both the flugel and
my trumpet. I'm going to Mallorca in a few days and I want to take both
with me, as well as my horn. It's a Marcus Bonna case. Very strong and
lightweight.
8th-11th July
A couple of concerts in Mallorca. I was in a new group - a brass sextet
called "Tuba Mirum". the instrumentation was like a regular
brass quintet line-up but with an extra trumpet part. The players as follows:
Trumpet: John Wallace
Trumpet: Andreas Koenig
Trumpet: Valentin Garvie
Horn: Myself.
Trombone: Leon Ni
Tuba: Oren Marshall.
What a fantastic four days! We had the luxury of two whole days for rehearsals
before the concert days and the group really worked well together, right
from the start. It was quite a varied and dangerous program. The audiences
were very responsive and the atmosphere was great as a result. John, Oren
and I played solo pieces, which were possibly the most challenging for
our audiences. Mine was called "Lost In Space" - a 7 movement
improvisation involving the use of a flugelhorn on the opposite side of
the stage, linked to where I sat with my horn by a long length of hosepipe.
Valentin did brilliant arrangements of a couple Tangos for the group and
nobody seemed to mind me trying to do some jazz improvisation in the extended
take-it-in-turns middle section. I swaggered out to the front, aimed high
and blasted out my stuff as loud as I possibly could. It must have been
a complete load of rubbish! Still, it was fun - and at least it felt like
jazz. The trumpet felt really comfortable and natural in my hands.
31st July
I'm on holiday with Carrie, Cai and Zak in a cottage in Sherringham Park,
Norfolk. Nobody lives anywhere nearby so I can practice at anytime and
most of what I've done so far has been outside.. I've brought Kenny's
Benge pocket-trumpet with me and I'm doing irregular bursts of modes and
jazz-chord arpeggios (from an exercise I've written called "Lodes
of Modes" which I'll post here one of these days [DONE
IT click here!] (and then click here)
and the odd stab at repeat tonguing in the high register - something I
find rather difficult. So, I'm not really being very systematic but then
this is a holiday. I guess what I'm doing adds up to about 90 minutes
or so each day. The little Benge is perfect for a holiday practice trumpet.
It takes up almost no space - it even fits inside my regular horn case
- and, most importantly, it's a serious piece of gear - an excellent instrument
by any standards. With a cup mute in it's nice and quiet so it doesn't
disturb the kids trying to get to sleep.
This evening, I've just discovered a good way forward. I
sat down with Aebersold's Turnarounds book and CD (volume 16) and tackled
the progressions for what are called "Turnarounds No 3". It's
basically this progression: DM,F7, BbM,Eb7 repeated three times followed
by a variety of unsubtle modulations into another key - and through all
the keys. I started off by playing along with the CD but soon realised
I was just deepening previous grooves I had made rather than finding new
pathways. I turned off the playalong and started to play just the chord
notes of each chord symbol. Difficult! Ken Bartells was right - I must
learn to know what notes I am playing and learn play ones I choose rather
than playing exclusively by ear. So here's a new personal axiom for me:
The ability to play by ear is certainly useful but
it's not enough for jazz
and can even be a drawback when it diverts me away from the
thorough learning process which I really must go through.
1st August
Following on from that I thought I would try some serious practice of
what Ken Bartells taught me (a year ago!). In my Psion Revo, a pocket
computer, I keep many useful files, one which is a spreadsheet in the
form of a randomised row of chord symbols. There are 11 chord types for
each of the twelve notes - thus 132 in all. Here are the some of them
to give an idea of their randomness:
BbM +4, C7 -9, F7+, Bb mM, D mM, A, A7 +4, AM +4, CØ,
E7+, C# mM, F mM, B°, Eb7 +4, G7 +4, FM +4, G°, B7, Ebm, D7 +9,
EbM +4, BbØ, DØ, Bb7, C7, Db7 -9, Bb7 -9, BM +4, C7 +9,
DM +4, Fm, FØ, F7 -9, D, EbØ etc...
Taking the first string of four chords from this random row: BbM +4,
C7 -9, F7+, Bb mM. I played through each one in turn. First up and down
the chords, then as scales, trying to hear the next one coming before
actually playing it. After beginning to get the feel of this I programmed
the sequence into the Yamaha QY70 and got it to repeat the four chords
around and around in a variety of stimulating styles such as "Bossa
Nova" or "Cool Jazz" (better described as tepid). Good
fun and, I think, very stimulating of the right kind of neural links for
hearing the flavours of chords just by looking at their written symbols.
Progress, I think.
4th August
Today I read something great. It is a quote from the pianist Howard Levy:
"Really, the best
way to learn is to take tunes off records, because you're utilizing your
ear. It takes a lot of knowledge and experience to be able to do this,
but it becomes so easy to hear pieces in their component parts if you
actually do the work yourself. Then you start trying to write the changes
out by ear. In the beginning, you're going to write out things wrong.
You're not going to know what's right for the first few years that you
do this. But in the end, you see your mistakes and you really learn it."
( I found this quote on page 93 of Paul F. Berliner's wonderful book,
"Thinking in Jazz - The Infinite Art of Improvisation". It's
a massive scholarly book, full pithy wisdom and mind- expanding quotes
by all sorts of famous and not so famous musicians. Published by The University
of Chicago Press ISBN 0-226-04381-9 )
8th August
I wrote out all the chords from Coltrane's "Giant Steps" and
turned them all into a useful chordal study which goes through every key.
Felt quite pleased with myself. It's a bit of an ear bender, so learning
to play it in every key might take some time.
I've also extracted a useful exercise from Clifford Brown's amazing "Night
in Tunisia" from an album called "The Beginning And The End".
It's based on a whole tone run and it's very tricky and makes a challenging
study for the ears and fingers. Something to put into my workout.
13th August
Becoming a bit frustrated by not getting enough study time. We are on
holiday and the kids need occupying, taking out, playing with etc. for
many hours each day. On top of that I have get my horn chops working because
I've a couple of hard gigs at the end of the week, in Germany and Italy
with London Brass. As usual with that crowd it's a new pad (to me) and
I have precisely three and a hours of rehearsal time in which to learn
how to play Richard Bissill's stupendously difficult horn parts. (For
the record I will say, with a casual confidence, that Richard Bissill
is the best horn player in the world).
The scraps of trumpet practice I have managed in the last few days have
been on arpeggios and scales. I really need to start learning some standards
and trumpet solos from recordings.
I've been running quite a lot (something else which shortens my available
practice time) and I always listen to music on minidisc as I run. Due
to a mix up last week I found I had inadvertently kept a disc which John
Barclay lent me. After an hour or so of listening I found he had recorded
it in LP mode, which means you can cram more music on the disc. He had
used not just LP mode, but LP4 mode, which give an available 300 minutes
(5 hours!) of music on just one disc. The quality is not so good but it's
really not bad and certainly good enough for the vintage jazz recordings
which John had copied. I confess I didn't really notice the poor sound
as I was running.
The amazing thing is that John has recorded himself playing along with
some of the tracks, so every now and again another trumpet player pops
up - in a different sound, in a different acoustic. John, a closet jazzer,
is very good! He's got a wonderful sound, a great understanding of jazz
harmony and bags of style. What's funny about it is that even though,
I guess, he recorded the stuff on his own at his home without any idea
that someone else might one day listen to it, he still sounds apologetic,
as if he's poking his head around a door and saying, "hello? does
anyone mind if I just squeeze in here and play along with you guys - just
a few quiet twiddles - don't mind me, I'm only messing about..."
Such a superb musician - he's obviously going to be a great jazzer (the
world awaits) but such a humble soul. Oh yes, and he just happens to be
one of the funniest men I have ever met. John and I have a plan to spend
some time together thrashing out some jazz. I'm expecting to learn a lot
from him - but I can't imagine he'll learn anything from me.
17th August
In Udine, the day after a London Brass concert. Gareth Small very kindly
lent me his Bb trumpet for the morning - and I had remembered to take
my trumpet mouthpiece with me. I did at least 90 minutes of really useful
practice. Lodes of Modes and that Clifford. Brown wholetone exercise.
No distractions - I really enjoyed it.
20th August
Just got home back from the London Brass concerts and started practicing
trumpet again. It was great to be away with London Brass, partly because
John Barclay was playing. Hearing him warming up (not that he bothers
with that much) and noodling jazzily around - to say nothing of the several
brilliant solos he played in the concerts - was all very inspiring.
Looking in the diary I seem to have plenty of free time over the next
couple of weeks so I should be able to get plenty of practice in.
21st August
Since reading that the best way forward is to learn solos from recordings
I've embarked on some study in that direction. The PC has turned out to
be a great help. I ripped a Chet Baker track, "Bea's Flat" (1953)
into the PC and then opened it in a .wav file editor. The trumpet solo
is very fast and at normal speed it's extremely difficult to hear the
individual notes so it's wonderful to be able to slow it down and yet
keep the pitch of the original. Normally, if you half the tempo of a recording
its pitch drops by an octave but the computer works its magic to compensate
precisely so that the correct pitch is retained. With this wonderful tool,
within half an hour or so I had untangled the first few bars of the solo
and even learned a bit of it -much quicker than I could have done just
using a CD player. Still, it's going to take some hard work to get my
playing of it up to Chet Baker's very fast tempo.
The PC has just opened up a whole new way of studying jazz for me.
Later today I met up with Julian Jacobson, a wonderful pianist
based in London. I used to play with him quite a lot in the early eighties
in a chamber ensemble called "Capricorn". We always used to
mess about together in rehearsals by playing scraps of music completely
out of context - we couldn't stop ourselves; most of what Capricorn played
was so boring and difficult that we needed plenty of light relief to keep
us sane. With this in mind and thinking Julian must still be some kind
of a closet jazzer, I rang him a to see if he could help me. It was a
positive hit - we made a date and that date was today.
On his suggestion we met up at the Royal College of Music where he and
I both teach. We were both a little awkward to start with and after a
bit of a natter we got down to some playing. We started with some blues
and then played Stella and a couple of other tunes I didn't know and couldn't
read. I must admit I was pretty shockingly bad but honest about my current
limitations and my intentions and, amazingly, he seemed keen to do some
more so we are going to meet again in November having, we hope, found
a drummer and a bass player. This is a very exciting development for me!
I need to learn some tunes!
23rd August
I was in Waterstones browsing the jazz books today when I discovered this
quote from Kieth Jarrett from "Jazztimes", May 1999
"Jazz is one of the least learnable art forms!"
Amen.
27th August
Right now I'm well stuck into some "turnaround" exercises. The
one I'm currently chopping away at is one of the simplest from Aebersold's
book of turnarounds (Volume 16, Ex. 3). Basically, this is a four chord
repeating sequence, for example F#M, A7, D7, G7, which needs transposing
into all keys. It's making me do what Ken Bartells told me to do a year
ago, which is to try to be conscious of which notes and what chord I'm
playing. I still find this really difficult but I'm confident that I'm
going to crack it eventually.
Another landmark I've passed recently, I now realise, is what might be
called the acquisition of "trumpet finger pitch". Ever since
I can remember I've had "horn finger pitch" meaning that I only
have to imagine I'm holding a horn and make a certain valve combination
for the note I'm wanting to hear to pop conveniently into my mind. This
is an extremely useful thing, particularly for playing atonal music -
in fact I don't know how anyone could play the stuff without that having
this facility.
Although the trumpet is in Bb, just like the French horn, the hornplayer
reads and thinks in F. Thus, while the trumpet fingerings are quite similar
between horn and trumpet (although one octave apart) the notes have completely
different names. On one level, then, trumpet fingering is completey different
to horn fingering - which is, I think, why hornplayers and trumpet players
are now an entirely different species and generally do not interbreed.
I must be quite a rare "sport" or crossbreed.
Now that I can "activate" my right hand and imagine certain
trumpet piston combinations to get any pitches I want in my head I think
I can say I have got "trumpet finger pitch". It's taken longer
than a year to acquire this, and I wasn't sure it would come - in fact
I was actaully slightly worried that if it did come it would mess up my
horn pitch. Luckily, trumpet fingers and horn fingers, being on different
hands, don't seem to conflict at all. Phew!
27th August
Spent a while ripping some carefully chosen Aebersold tracks into MP3
files in my PC. I've done this so that I can open the tracks up in special
software which enables me to slow all or part of the tracks down, loop
them or transpose them, or do all those things (Don't worry Jamey, I'm
not going to make them available on the www - they're for my own use only!).
I've found it's a very efficient way of disecting jazz solos for learning
them by ear.
29th August
Valentin Garvie came around this evening. He had phoned up to say he was
in London for four days between a tour around Sweden and a pile of work
with Ensemble Moderm in Germany, so I invited him around straight away.
We played through a few blues pieces and one or two standards, all with
the Aebersold playalongs.
To summarise what came out of the evening:
1. I've improved a bit since the last time we tried this
together, which is encouraging in itself, but in addition Valentin was
particularly encouraging. He's very good at delivering praise and encouragement
wrapped up neatly with some constructive criticism. (If you are reading
this, Valentin, THANKS!)
2. My polycarbonate mouthpiece is really not bad - we did
a sound test and the differences were not quite so obvious as they had
seemed last time we compared it with his metal 1.5c.
3. Valentin is a really good jazzer! I don't know why he
hasn't been doing more of it. As we got warmed up he got much better,
very rapidly, indicating that he has been very good at jazz improvisation
in the past but has let it get a bit rusty. After half an hour or so he
was producing some amazingly impressive stuff and by comparison I felt
I was sounding worse and worse. The most noticable thing for me was that
I don't seem to have any sort of style, rather I play in what might be
called the "Blandissimo" style. The gin didn't help. For a moment
or two I felt like giving up but then Valentin managed to find yet more
encouragement, somehow.
4. He agreed wholeheartedly with "Really,
the best way to learn is to take tunes off records..".
(see full quote, in green, above).
5. He thinks that rather than trying to learn all the turnarounds,
all the two-five-ones, all the blues progressions in every key etc. (not
that I have been, entirely...) I should I should stick to the simpler
more common keys only and concentrate my efforts more on learning a big
repertoire of patterns, licks, riffs, whatever they are called, extracted
from recorded solos. I must find a ways of chaining chunks of this sort
of remembered material together in my improvisation. Hopefully, this should
to prevent me meandering around aimlessly, which is what I tend to do
when I'm reading chord symbols.
Now, that's a lot of learning in one evening - and all it
cost me was the preparation of a bowl of stif-fried vegetables with rice
and a gin&tonic!
(6. I must persuade Valentin to come over more often.)
30th August
Valentin's visit has made quite a difference. This morning I made an assault
on Chet Baker's amazing solo from "Bea's Flat". I spent an hour
or so looping sections of it at half-speed and trying to capture every
not and every nuance. It's coming along quite well, I think - I've learned
about 75% of it (at half speed). Another hour on it and I should have
it, and then I can start speeding it up.
After that bit of work I opened up a blues file in the same key, C, in
my computer and was delighted to find I could fit bits of the solo from
Bea's Flat quite nicely here and there. This ties in very immediately
with something I read last night in Paul Berliner's book. Here it is:
Rhythmic
ingredients can also constitute the fundamental idea for original figures.
Walter Bishop Jr. says that after absorbing Bud Powell's phrasing he "began
to thnk like Bud" so he could abandon Powell's precise lines and
create his own "in the same idiom, playing with the same kind of
feeling and intensity". Arthur Rhames views the process as analogous
to emulating personal styles of speech. Because all artists speak with
"their own natural rhythm and sequential order." it is possible
to "emulate a person whose speaking you like, using his same effect
- how he comes into a sentence or the way he constructs his things"
- but without saying the "exact same thing". That is how Rhames
learned from John Coltrane.
"Without
directly copying his melodic line, I tried to get the feeling of the line,
the phrasing, which allowed me to understand how Trane was talking when
he played. What I wanted was the form, the basket that he was using, but
the contents I wanted to fill myself. I knew that I had something to say,
and I wanted to deal with that. So what I copied was the way John constructed
his phrases and their rhythmical base, the stems without the notes, and
I put my own noes and harmony - the things I thought about - on top of
it."
20th September.
I spent a bit of time over at Jim Rattigan's house yesterday. We did
some rather basic work on 2-5-1 progressions. Exactly what I needed. Then
we worked a bit on "All The Things You Are". Here's a lead
sheet.
2003
17th March (bit of a long gap!).
Still practising!
Here's an excersise I'm working on a bit now. The idea of it is to get
me right into the feel, into the nitty-gritty, of the melodic minor by
getting used to some awkward angular intervals contained within it. The
melodic minor (up) or MinorMajor scale is so useful because its modes
yield a lot of common jazz scales, such as the altered "Alt"
scale (7th mode) or the half-diminished scale with a raised 2nd (Locrian
#2).
I'm going to try to learn this in all twelve mM scales. It's very awkward,
particularly in the keys furthest away from C. Gulp!
20th April 2003(another long gap!)
Still practising! I've been working on John Coltrane's essential standard,
Giant Steps. It's a real earbender, but I think I've found a way in -
an initial way of taking the fear out of it.
It's a colour coded grid of the chord changes. Pretty self explanatory.
It shows that the whole piece can be done, as if by magic, using only
the notes of three major scales - in this case Db major, A major and F
major. The three colours correspond to the three chords so you get visual
cue to change chord. Please take a look.
Please note it's for Bb trumpet. I use it with the excellent slow Aebersold
playalongs to Giant Steps found in volume 65, "Four and More".
2004
1/1/04 (another, even longer, gap!)
New year's resolution: to get this diary/journal going again after quite
a long period of neglect (look at the date of the previous entry).
A large part of what stopped me writing was that every time I thought
of doing so I felt the time would be better spent practising the trumpet.
Also I lost the sense of importance of keeping a progress record. One
of the things I like to do is to teach, and it's not inconceivable that
one day I might teach jazz, perhaps specifically to people who are already
"classically" trained. If I do, then a well-kept journal, of
my own trials and tribulations, could be a very useful teaching resource
for me. Not only that - I do think that what I'm attempting is unique;
I've never heard of an established horn player switching not only instrument
but an entire musical discipline before. I feel something of an explorer,
and I suppose a good explorer makes maps as they go along.
Apart from a period of some four months last summer during which I worked
quite intensively for the London Philharmonic Orchestra at Glyndebourne
Opera, I have been working pretty hard at my jazz. I'm still a long way
from any kind of public performance but I've not lost any of my enthusiasm
or energy for the task of learning. .
During the period since my last writinng here my collection of playalong
recordings has enlarged quite a lot and nearly all of them are Jamey Aebersold's
excellent books. Also I've found another absolutely great tool to help
me learn. It's a software program called The Amazing Slowdowner (available
to download from www.ronimusic.com
). This extremely clever software will get hold of the CD player in your
PC or Mac and make it do the most amazing things. It can play a track
- all of it or just a section of it - looped if you like if you like if
you like if you like - at any speed without altering the pitch. This is
incredibly useful in itself but there's more - it can transpose the pitch
of the track up or down by any amount you want - semitones or fractions
of semitones or combinations thereof - up or down. The great thing is
that pitch and tempo can be chosen independantly of eachother. It's an
incredibly easy to use, no frills, sensibly written program. Congratulations
to the author - a jazz musician himself, for turning my PC into the most
useful learning tool I could imagine for my jazz.
I keep finding new ways to use it but here's one way, just to help demonstrate
how useful it is: say I want to learn a solo by Clifford Brown - from
one of his recordings. I'll put the CD in (or I can rip the desired track
to an MP3 file and store it in my computer for ease of access - The Amazing
Slowdowner works just as well with MP3 files, or other types of audio
files on hard-disk, as with a CD spinning in your drive) and find the
start of the actual solo and set it to loop the first bar or two - a chunk
small enough for me to learn without breaking it down still further. I'll
slow it right down so I can hear every little detail and then commence
trying to play it. When I've got it, I'll start to speed it up a little
and move onto the next chunk.
It's the ability to play around with the speed of the playback and the
length of the loop which is so wonderfully useful. It's hard to imagine
a more efficient way of learning something by ear. And I'm now certain
that "by ear" is the way to do it. I've a book of Clifford Brown's
solos transcribed and printed. They certainly look nice but if you play
them "from the dots" they come out sounding stilted and mechanical.
I reckon the only way you'll get it to float, fly and dance like Clifford
Brown is by copying him directly. And that's why we learn solos, isn't
it? Jazz is supposed to be an aural tradition. I want to learn Clifford
Brown's rhythms, grammar, syntnax, accent and dialect - and I can't do
that from a book. My best chance is with the great man's recordings and
the Amazinng Slowdowner. This is the way it's always been done, incidentnally.
It used to be constant repositioning of the needle on a 78 record - and
I've heard it said that many jazz musicians used completely wear out their
records learning like this!
The Amazing Slowdowner is much more efficient - and you can learn it
in a differnet key from the original, if you want.
A lot of the Aebersold playalongs are still too fast for me to get my
head around the chord changes. With the Slowdowner I can highlight any
tricky bits and run them as slowly as I like until I've got the hang of
it, then speed it up bit by bit.
Incidentally, I've been very surprised and humbled by putting Clifford
Brown's solos under the microscope in this way. One would think that the
more you slow it down to disect and investigate it the more minor imperfections
of rythm and intonation would show up until, at high magnifications, it
would start sounding rather ragged. Wrong! What has been a most amazing
ear-opener for me has been the discovery that the more I dissect and magngfy
the more detail and accuracy is revealed. Hats off to the incredible Clifford
Brown.
9/2/04
I've just spent a week in Antwerp, Belgium, playing Schubert's 9th Symphony
with the Flanders Filharmonic orchestra (KFOV)
and stayed with an old friend and fine photographer, Miel
Pieters, a fiddle player in the orchestra. Here's are some pictures
he took of me practising my Benge pocket trumpet. It's perfect for travelling
as it fits in my horncase - and there's still room for the horn.
16th February 2004
After a long period of fairly intense study I'm now having something of
a lull in the trumpet practise due to being busy every day recording from
dawn to dusk at Abbey Road Studio One, the film score of Troy, playing
the bigger, curlier thing in F (go here
if you want to see some pictures of that).
This does not mean total cessation, though. Far from it; I am lugging
around with me a new book by George Bouchard.
I've been studying this on my fingers and in my head in
the studio and on the underground and have found some very intrigueing
stuff about use of what Bouchard calls the "Altered Pentatonic"
scale. The notes of this scale, if it starts on C, are C, D, Eb, G ,A.
This doesn't look like much but it's a huge chunk of learning. I want
to learn them in all keys, first of all, and then learn use them out of
their root keys in the clever way Bouchard describes for use over dominant,
altered and half-diminished chords. For example the C pentatonic shown
above will sound great played over B7+9 or over Aø.
This is poing to be a big job for me, particlarly as I'll have to learn
to play a scale with a C "feel" over a B "feel" harmony.
I haven't tried this yet but I as can't hear the damn thing in my head
yet I know it's going to be problematic. A very good challenge, though,
and Bouchard is pretty insistent that it sounds great.
I can't tell you how good I feel about being "intermediate".
It's a such a great leap up from being a beginner and I hope to remain
here for a very long time, and make the absolute most of it.
To finish today's entry, here's a photo taken last night
at Abbey Road, during an "overdub" session for the film, Troy.
It's an impressive brass line up but the two biggest highlights are my
jazzdaddy and teacher, John Barclay, 2nd trumpet from the left and, far
right, England's greatest living lead trumpet legend, - and designer of
my trumpet - Derek Watkins.
Incidentally, this overdub session gives a total weight of brass, for
some parts of the score, of 16 trumpets, 16 trombones, 16 horns and 3
tubas. Utterly awesome!
9th April 2004
Before:
I've been practising pretty regularly and, I feel, steadily improving but increasingly feeling myself to be in a music vacuum. What I need now is fresh air, not my own stale stuff to breathe; so with that in mind I've arranged to have a lesson with Martin Shaw, who has been enethusiastically recommended by both John Barclay and Derek Watkins.
I'm taking a trumpet and a flugelhorn but no books or printed stuff of any kind - jazz is supposed to be an improvisational musical form - plus I don't want to be in a position of telling Martin the way I want the lesson to go.
What do I want? Not sure, but I'd like him to get me loosened up my playing and then gently guide me towards better ways of doing it. The fact is I don't know if I'm any good at any aspect of it. John Barclay has been vey encouraging, even flattering, and so have Valentin and Dan Newall, but I don't really know if I'm heading in the "right" direction, hence the need for a lesson ...or several.
After:
Well, that was amazing. Martin Shaw is a great teacher, and very generous with his time. He gave me two hours! It felt like half an hour. It seems that I'm basically on the right track and he was very encouraging about my attempts - after hearing me struggling through All The Things You Are, although a few things came up which I'm writing down now to remind myself about.
1. General articulation: I'm doing it too softly! My tonguing needs to be more positive, or harder, less "classical" - this surprised me but he demonstrated the difference and convinced me. It's part of coming from my highly classical horn technique and rounding the starts of the notes. "It's a beautiful sound but not right for jazz trumpet", I think he said. So I must try to remember that.
2. Learning the modal flavours: Up and down scales thinking in terms of raised and lowered 2nds, 3rds, 6ths etc.. Make cards or use Psion... Go to the ninth and back down each time. Then learn them from the ninth down then up. Then in broken thirds, fourths etc...
3. Playing Aebersolds using only the chord notes. Up, then up and down.
4. Playing Aebersolds up and down the straight simple scales notes - so, for example, when encountering the altered scale Calt, just stick to C7 (for now).
5. Same as above but improvising using only the scale notes first in minims, then in triplet minims, then crotchets, then triplet crotchets then quavers, then, triplet quevers etc...
6. Don't use double tonguing in the fast stuff - it's almost never done in jazz. The fast licks seem to all be slurred pairs or threes, across the main beats.
7. Learn the closed-tongue Clifford Brown thingy sound. Like muting the sound by putting the toungue against the teeth so the air has to squeeze around the teeth to get through. This is a new departure - something unheard of in classical technique and I don't think it's been analyzed yet by jazz trumpet players. They just do it.
8. The timbre can be less bright - Martin's was considerably smokier, or more lush than mine. No idea how to do this.
9. Chromatic scales: very useful and need to be clean and accurate and fast. Good for warming up. Use a more postive finger action - slam the valves down a bit more !
Thank you Martin!
6th May 2004
I've had another amazing lesson with Martin Shaw.
We spent quite a long time looking into what we have agreed to call "Ghost" tonguing. Having done a bit of work on it since the last lesson and got somewhere (though by no means anywhere near it yet) it's now got a little clearer exactly what I have to do. So now I have an exercise I will put into my work-out to teach my tongue to jump in and out of that precise position on my upper incisors which damps the sound. It's a great effect and I'm chasing after it seriously.
The second half of the lesson was spent trying to find a way of using the ghost tonguing in context. Martin wrote out a couple of little riffs for me, which would work over a 2-5-1 sequence and which contain obviousd places to do the ghost notes.
We talked quite a lot about how dificult it is for me actually to hear some of the things that Martin does (he does play really beautifully) well enough to even try to copy him. He worked through a variety of ways of slowing it down, with me listening and copying, but not getting anywhere near it. Mine always sounded clumsy and awkward - his always fresh and alive and perfect.
I think next time I'll have to bring the minidisc recorder so I can better analyzing exactly what's going on. I need to do this not just with the ghost notes but with many other aspects of style.
My articulation still needs to be blunter, firmer and more immediate at the front of the notes. I still sound too much like a horn player - shaping everything. Despite this being quite a profound change in style, I'm completely confident it won't mess up my horn playing , as it seems to me that people who learn to speak French don't lose their Engish accent in the process. I'm sure it's exactly the same thing. The parallel with learning a foreign language is very clear to me
Martin also said I need to listen to tons of Clifford Brown. Fantastic! I'll try to learn some more of his solos.
Homework:
1. Continue the chromatic runs and practise ghost tonguing as workout exercises.
2. Practise the riffs Martin gave me.
3. Study "Confirmation" by Charlie Parker - from the copy Martin lent me with articulations and other useful pencil marks added.
4. Get hold of David Baker's book on Clifford Brown in the Giants Of Jazz series.
5. Get hold of the Charlie Parker Onmibus.
6. Tongue firmer all the time.
7. Listen to Clifford Brown. Listen to Clifford Brown. Listen to Clifford Brown. Listen to Clifford Brown. Listen to Clifford Brown.